Countries and territories

Countries made of islands: island nations versus archipelagic states

Abstract illustration of a patchwork of borders and capital markers in red and blue tones

In 2017 Indonesia told a United Nations conference that it had reported 16,056 named islands. The same paper said the figure most often quoted is 17,504 and that no official legal document confirms the number. A country built from islands cannot settle a simple count, and that says something about the topic.

Counting is only one of the questions. A country made of islands also needs a legal definition of an island, a rule for drawing its outer limits and a way to treat the water between the pieces. This article covers all three, using the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea as the main reference.

What counts as an island

Article 121 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea gives the standard definition: an island is a naturally formed area of land, surrounded by water, which is above water at high tide. Two details matter for counting. A sandbar that disappears at high tide is not an island, and a rock that cannot sustain human habitation or economic life of its own has no exclusive economic zone or continental shelf of its own.

Even with a clear definition, totals move. Surveys improve, names are checked in the field and features are added or removed. Indonesia's paper to the UN Group of Experts on Geographical Names describes this process in detail: data collection through field surveys, then verification by local and technical teams, then a national gazetteer.

Three ways of counting the islands of Indonesia, from a paper Indonesia submitted to the UN in 2017
FigureCountWhat it means
Reported to the UN in 201213,466Islands reported at the 2012 UN conference
Added in 20172,590Further islands reported at the 2017 conference
Total reported to the UN as of 201716,056The 2012 and 2017 reports combined
Figure widely quoted in the literature17,504No official legal document confirms it, says the paper

Island nation versus archipelagic state

"Island nation" is an everyday phrase for a country whose territory lies entirely on islands. "Archipelagic State" is a legal term with conditions attached. Part IV of the Convention defines it as a state constituted wholly by one or more archipelagos, which may include other islands. An archipelago, in turn, is a group of islands with interconnecting waters and other natural features so closely interrelated that they form an intrinsic geographical, economic and political entity, or that have historically been regarded as one.

Main rules for archipelagic States in Part IV of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea
RuleWhat the Convention saysArticle
Water-to-land ratioInside the baselines, the ratio of water to land must be between 1 to 1 and 9 to 147
Baseline lengthUp to 100 nautical miles (about 185 km); up to 3 percent of the baselines may reach 125 nautical miles (about 232 km)47
Archipelagic watersSovereignty extends to the waters inside the baselines, regardless of depth or distance from the coast49
Measuring the sea zonesThe territorial sea and other zones are measured from the archipelagic baselines48

The practical result is that an archipelagic State is treated as one unit. The sea between its islands is part of the country, not a gap in it. Not every island country qualifies, since the ratio and the baseline limits have to be met. For the wider picture of the ocean beyond those limits, see the world's oceans.

How a country spread over many islands holds together

Kiribati shows how far such a country can stretch. Britannica says it consists of 33 islands and that only about 20 of them are inhabited. They fall into three main groups, the Gilbert, Phoenix and Line islands, plus Banaba. By Britannica’s measure the country extends about 2,900 km (1,800 mi) from the Gilberts in the west to the Line Islands in the east; other references give larger figures because they pick different end points.

That layout explains several map habits. A map of an island country often needs an inset or a zoom, because the land is small and the spread is wide. Counting inhabited and uninhabited islands separately avoids confusion. And the country's extent is the whole group together with its waters, not one big shape. The same logic applies to island territories that belong to larger states, which are covered in dependent territories explained. For the Pacific groupings, see Oceania and the Pacific island regions.

When one island holds more than one country

Island and country do not always match. Britannica describes Borneo as divided among three political units. Indonesia holds the largest part, Malaysia has the northern fourth through Sarawak and Sabah, and Brunei lies on the northern coast, surrounded on all land sides by Sarawak. Hispaniola is shared by two countries: Haiti on the western third and the Dominican Republic on the eastern two-thirds.

Before you call a country an island nation
  • Check that all of its territory lies on islands, not only the main part.
  • Ask whether it shares its main island with another country, as on Borneo or Hispaniola.
  • Separate the informal phrase "island nation" from the legal term "archipelagic State".
  • State which count of islands you use, and say whether uninhabited ones are included.
  • Name your source and the year, because island totals change as surveys improve.

Shared islands also raise questions about lines on the ground. The article on how borders are drawn shows how such boundaries are set, and landlocked countries covers the opposite situation, a country with no ocean coast.

Common mistakes about island countries

  • Treating "island nation" and "archipelagic State" as the same thing

    The first is a casual phrase. The second is a legal category in Part IV of the Convention with a water-to-land ratio and limits on baseline length. A country can be an island nation without meeting those conditions.

  • Quoting one island count as settled

    Indonesia's own paper lists 13,466, then 16,056 and a widely quoted 17,504. Say which figure you use and the year of the report behind it.

  • Counting features that are not islands

    Under Article 121, an island must be above water at high tide. A sandbar covered at high tide does not count, and a rock that cannot sustain human habitation or economic life of its own gets no exclusive economic zone.

  • Assuming one island means one country

    Borneo holds three political units and Hispaniola holds two. Do not label a whole island with the name of one country.

  • Judging a country by its land area alone

    For an archipelagic State the waters inside the baselines are part of the territory. Kiribati has 33 islands spread over about 2,900 km, so its extent is far larger than the sum of its land.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an island nation and an archipelagic state?

An island nation is an informal term for a country whose territory is entirely on islands. An archipelagic State is a legal term in Part IV of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, for a state constituted wholly by one or more archipelagos, which may draw baselines around them if it meets the water-to-land ratio and other conditions.

How many islands does Indonesia have?

The figure most often quoted is 17,504, but Indonesia's own 2017 paper to the UN says no official legal document confirms it. Indonesia had reported 16,056 named islands to the UN as of 2017: 13,466 in 2012 and 2,590 more in 2017.

What counts as an island in international law?

Article 121 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea defines an island as a naturally formed area of land, surrounded by water, which is above water at high tide. Rocks that cannot sustain human habitation or economic life of their own have no exclusive economic zone or continental shelf.

Can two countries share one island?

Yes. Britannica describes Borneo as divided among Indonesia, Malaysia and Brunei, and Hispaniola as shared by Haiti in the west and the Dominican Republic in the east.

Does the sea between the islands belong to an archipelagic state?

Under Article 49, the sovereignty of an archipelagic State extends to the waters enclosed by its archipelagic baselines, which the Convention calls archipelagic waters, regardless of their depth or distance from the coast. The state must have drawn the baselines under Article 47.

Sources

  1. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Part IV: Archipelagic States United Nations
  2. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Part VIII: Regime of Islands United Nations
  3. Identification of Islands and Standardization of Their Names (paper submitted by Indonesia) UN Group of Experts on Geographical Names, 11th UN Conference on the Standardization of Geographical Names, 2017
  4. Kiribati Encyclopaedia Britannica
  5. Borneo Encyclopaedia Britannica
  6. Hispaniola Encyclopaedia Britannica

Keep a record of the places you have been, and see what share of the world you have covered.

Open the travel map editor