Rivers, ridgelines and straight lines: how borders get drawn
The land border between Canada and the United States runs 8,891 kilometers (5,525 miles). The International Boundary Commission that looks after it says the line on land is a series of straight lines joined at boundary monuments, and the line on water is a series of straight lines joined at turning points. A border that looks like a winding river on a map is, on paper, a list of points.
That gap between what a map shows and how a line is defined explains most questions about borders. This guide covers the main ways lines are chosen, what can go wrong with each, and how a treaty description becomes markers on the ground. It does not cover disputes. Where a line is contested, the honest summary is that status is disputed.
Four common ways to define a line
A border is first delimited, meaning it is described in a treaty or an agreement. Later it is demarcated, meaning it is marked on the ground. Delimitation is the choice of rule. The rule is usually one of four kinds, and many borders mix them. Which rule fits depends on the terrain, on the surveying tools available when the agreement was signed and on what both sides were able to agree.
| Rule | How it works | Known weak point | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| River | The line follows the middle or the deepest channel | The channel can move | Rio Grande, as described in an 1848 treaty |
| Lake | Often the median line, every point equidistant from the opposite shores | Shorelines change with water levels | Most lake boundaries, according to Srebro |
| Mountain crest or watershed | The line follows the ridge or the divide between drainage basins | High crests do not always match the watershed; glaciers retreat | Italy with Austria and Switzerland |
| Straight line | The line follows a parallel, a meridian or points joined by straight sections | Ignores terrain and local communities | The 49th parallel in the Canada-US boundary |
Haim Srebro, writing for the International Federation of Surveyors in 2021, notes that most international boundaries have their roots in the 19th century and the early 20th century. Many were drawn with straight lines or other lines that did not take local geography, history or communities into account. Today the choice of rule is still the first question to ask about any border.
Rivers: the middle, the deepest channel and the moving bed
Srebro writes that more than one third of the world's international boundaries are river boundaries. A treaty has to say which part of the river counts. The 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, for example, describes a stretch of the Rio Grande boundary as running "up the middle of that river, following the deepest channel, where it has more than one." The line of the deepest channel is called the thalweg.
Rivers change, so the law separates two cases. In accretion, the river moves slowly and gradually, and the boundary follows the new course. In avulsion, the river changes course suddenly, and the boundary stays in the old channel, even if it is now dry. Srebro traces these two principles to Roman times. For the physical side of rivers and their basins, see rivers and drainage basins.
Mountains: ridgelines that can move
Mountain crests and watersheds look like ready-made borders, and Srebro says they were widely chosen because they saved the work of marking a line on the ground. Two problems follow. A border along crests crosses valleys between peaks, and the highest crests do not always coincide with the watershed, which is the line that divides water flowing to different basins.
Glaciers add a third. Where a border follows an icy crest, melting reveals a rocky crest with a different watershed. Srebro reports that Italy and its northern neighbors, Austria and Switzerland, adopted a moving border approach: the boundary line follows the new location of the watershed. For how such ranges form, read how mountain ranges form.
Straight lines, treaties and the line on the ground
The Canada-US boundary shows treaties and straight lines at work. The International Boundary Commission lists the agreements behind it. Article II of the Convention of 1818 set the boundary along the 49th parallel from Lake of the Woods to the Rockies, and the Oregon Treaty of 1846 extended it west along the 49th parallel to the Strait of Georgia. The Commission also maintains more than 8,000 monuments and reference points and keeps a 6 meter (20 foot) clear vista along the land line.
Seas follow rules of their own. The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea lets a coastal state set a territorial sea up to 12 nautical miles (about 22 km) from its baselines, and it limits the exclusive economic zone to 200 nautical miles (about 370 km). Map readers who want to see how straight lines look on a flat page can read map projections explained. Borders also create the odd shapes covered in enclaves and exclaves.
How to read a border on a map
- Is the line straight? If so, it probably follows a parallel, a meridian or joined points set by treaty.
- Is it irregular and close to water? It may follow the middle or the deepest channel of a river or the median line of a lake.
- Does it follow a ridge? It may follow a crest or a watershed, and glaciers can shift it.
- Which treaty or agreement defines the line, and when was it signed?
- Is the line marked on the ground, or only described on paper?
Borders and the number of countries are linked. A border exists between two states, and the list of states is explained in how many countries are there. When status is disputed, say so instead of drawing a firm line.
Common mistakes about borders
- Assuming borders follow natural features
Many follow parallels, meridians or negotiated lines. The Canada-US line along the 49th parallel is a straight line set by treaty, not by terrain.
- Thinking a river border is fixed to today's water
Under the accretion principle the line follows slow changes. Under avulsion it stays in the old channel after a sudden change. The treaty language decides which rule applies.
- Believing a mountain border runs along the highest peaks
Srebro points out that high crests may not coincide with the general watershed lines. Read the exact wording of the agreement.
- Confusing the treaty line with the markers
Delimitation describes the line in words and demarcation marks it on the ground. The International Boundary Commission keeps more than 8,000 monuments and reference points in order for that reason.
- Treating every border as permanent
Rivers move, glaciers retreat and agreements can be revised. The moving border between Italy and its northern neighbors is built to change with the watershed.
Frequently asked questions
How are borders drawn?
Most borders are set by treaty or agreement. The agreement picks a rule, such as the middle of a river, a mountain crest or watershed, a parallel or meridian, or a list of coordinates. Surveyors then mark the line with monuments.
What is the difference between delimitation and demarcation?
Delimitation is the description of the border in a treaty or agreement. Demarcation is the marking of that line on the ground with monuments, pillars or clearings. A border can be delimited long before it is demarcated.
Does a river border move when the river moves?
It depends on how the river moves. If it shifts slowly and gradually, the principle of accretion usually moves the boundary with it. If the river changes course suddenly, the principle of avulsion keeps the boundary in the old channel.
Why are some borders perfectly straight?
They were drawn along a parallel or a meridian, or between points joined by straight lines. The Convention of 1818 and the Oregon Treaty of 1846 set the Canada-US boundary along the 49th parallel in this way. Straight lines are easy to describe but ignore terrain.
Can a border change because of climate?
In some places, yes. Where a border follows a glacier crest, melting can change the watershed. Italy, Austria and Switzerland have agreed that the line follows the new watershed, which is called a moving border.
Sources
- Unstable International Boundaries and FIG Publication No 76 International Federation of Surveyors (FIG), e-Working Week 2021
- The Boundary International Boundary Commission, Canada and United States
- Interesting Facts International Boundary Commission, Canada and United States
- History International Boundary Commission, Canada and United States
- Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, February 2, 1848 The Avalon Project, Yale Law School
- United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Part II: Territorial Sea and Contiguous Zone United Nations