Lesotho, Kaliningrad, Llívia: how enclaves and exclaves work
Lesotho is a whole country, yet every direction you travel from its borders leads into South Africa. Cabinda is a province of Angola, yet you cannot reach it from the rest of Angola by land without crossing another country. Both places look odd on a map, and both fall under a word that people often use for the other one.
The two words are enclave and exclave. They describe a place from two different points of view, and a single place can be both. This guide defines them, tests the definitions on seven real places and shows how to label such places without confusion.
Two words, two points of view
Britannica defines an enclave as a territory surrounded by foreign territory. The word comes from the Late Latin inclavatus, meaning shut in, which is a handy way to remember it. An exclave is a territory separated from the main part of the country it belongs to, and it can be surrounded by the territory of one or more foreign countries.
The difference is the point of view. An exclave is described from the side of the country that owns it. An enclave is described from the side of the country that surrounds it. Britannica notes that the same piece of land can be both: an exclave in relation to the state that has sovereignty over it, and an enclave in relation to the state around it.
Many references add one condition: an enclave is surrounded by a single country, so a place that touches two neighbors is usually called an exclave only. A whole country that is surrounded cannot be an exclave at all, because it is not part of anything larger. In everyday speech these rules are often relaxed, which is why you will see "enclave" used for places that are only mostly surrounded.
Three countries that are enclaves
Britannica describes Lesotho as completely encircled by South Africa and notes that only two other independent states are in the same position: Vatican City and San Marino. Both of those are encircled by Italy. All three are sovereign enclaves, which means they are not exclaves of anyone. Each also counts among the 195 countries in the travel map editor, because Lesotho and San Marino are UN member states and the Holy See is a UN observer state.
| State | Surrounded by | Surface area (UN Demographic Yearbook 2023) |
|---|---|---|
| Lesotho | South Africa | 30,355 km² (about 11,720 sq mi) |
| San Marino | Italy | 61 km² (about 24 sq mi) |
| Vatican City (Holy See) | Italy | 0.44 km² (about 0.17 sq mi) |
The areas show how wide the range is. Lesotho is roughly 500 times the size of San Marino, and San Marino is roughly 140 times the size of Vatican City. All three are also landlocked, but the reverse does not hold: most landlocked countries touch several neighbors, so they are not enclaves. The article on landlocked countries covers that wider group.
Exclaves and the treaties behind them
Exclaves usually come from lines drawn on paper long ago. Kaliningrad is Britannica's own example of an exclave: a Russian territory that lies between Lithuania and Poland. It touches two neighbors, so it is an exclave but not an enclave. Cabinda is a northern exclave of Angola on the Atlantic coast. Britannica says it covers 7,270 km² (2,807 sq mi), borders the Republic of the Congo to the north and is separated from the rest of Angola by part of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Llívia is the case that fits both words. Britannica calls it a town and an enclave of Spanish territory inside the French département of Pyrénées-Orientales. Under the 1659 Treaty of the Pyrenees, the villages of northern Cerdanya went to France, but Llívia counted as a town and stayed Spanish. A neutral road across French territory links it to Puigcerdà. From Spain's side it is an exclave, and from France's side it is an enclave.
| Place | Belongs to | Around it | Enclave? | Exclave? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lesotho | Itself | South Africa only | Yes | No |
| San Marino | Itself | Italy only | Yes | No |
| Vatican City | Itself (Holy See) | Italy only | Yes | No |
| Kaliningrad | Russia | Lithuania and Poland, plus the sea | No | Yes |
| Cabinda | Angola | Republic of the Congo, DR Congo and the sea | No | Yes |
| Llívia | Spain | France only | Yes | Yes |
| Oecussi Ambeno | Timor-Leste | See the note below | Loosely | Yes |
Usage in law is sometimes looser than the strict rules. The Constitution of Timor-Leste lists "the enclave of Oecussi Ambeno" as part of the national territory, alongside the eastern part of Timor, the island of Ataúro and the islet of Jaco. For how treaties turn into lines on the ground, see how borders are drawn.
How to show them on a map and in a list
On a political map, an exclave takes the color of its own country, not the color of its neighbors. A small one may need a label or an inset so readers do not miss it. In lists, record the place under the country that holds sovereignty, and add the surrounding country in a note when it helps.
- Ask which country owns the place. If the answer is "itself", it can be an enclave but never an exclave.
- Count the neighbors on land. One neighbor all around means an enclave; two or more means an exclave only.
- Check whether the place has a sea coast. If it does, say "semi-enclave" or use plain wording.
- Name the source for the status, such as a treaty, a constitution or an encyclopedia entry.
- Use the same color as the owning country on maps, and add an inset for tiny places.
Common mistakes with enclaves and exclaves
- Calling any isolated place an enclave
An enclave is surrounded by foreign territory. A part of your own country that lies apart from the main body is an exclave. Use the word that matches the point of view.
- Treating Lesotho, San Marino or Vatican City as exclaves
An exclave is part of a larger country. These three are independent states, so they are enclaves only. Britannica names them as the only independent states fully encircled by another country.
- Believing an exclave must be small
Llívia is a town, while Cabinda covers 7,270 km² according to Britannica. Size does not decide the label; separation does.
- Assuming a single neighbor
Kaliningrad lies between two countries and borders the sea, and Cabinda borders two countries and the Atlantic. A strict enclave has one neighbor all around. An exclave may have several.
- Mixing up enclave and landlocked
All three enclaved states are landlocked, but most landlocked countries touch several neighbors. Enclave describes a position inside one country, and landlocked describes a lack of ocean coast.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an enclave and an exclave?
An enclave is a territory surrounded by foreign territory. An exclave is a part of a country that is separated from its main part. They describe the same kind of oddity from two sides, and one place can be both.
Which countries are enclaves?
Lesotho, San Marino and Vatican City. Britannica describes Lesotho as encircled by South Africa and says San Marino and Vatican City are the only other independent states completely encircled by another country, in their case Italy.
Is Kaliningrad an enclave or an exclave?
It is an exclave of Russia. It lies between Lithuania and Poland, so it is not surrounded by a single country and does not qualify as an enclave in the strict sense.
Can a place be both an enclave and an exclave?
Yes. Llívia is a Spanish town inside France. From the viewpoint of Spain, which holds sovereignty, it is an exclave, and from the viewpoint of France, which surrounds it, it is an enclave.
Do exclaves like Cabinda count as separate countries in the editor?
No. Cabinda is part of Angola and Kaliningrad is part of Russia, so neither appears in the count of 195. Lesotho, San Marino and the Holy See are separate entries because they are states in their own right.
Sources
- What's the Difference Between Enclaves and Exclaves? Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Lesotho Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Cabinda Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Llívia Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Demographic Yearbook 2023, Table 3: Population, surface area and density United Nations Statistics Division
- Constitution of Timor-Leste (2002) Constitute Project