Recording your travels

Shading, pins or labels: choosing a style for your travel map

Abstract illustration of a dotted travel route linking pins across a map grid

The most common type of color vision deficiency makes red and green hard to tell apart, according to the U.S. National Eye Institute. Yet some travel maps use green for places visited and red for the rest. A style that looks obvious to its author can be unreadable to a share of the people who see the map, and that share includes some of your own family and friends.

A map style is really a set of separate decisions: how to mark a place (shading or pins), how to name it (full labels, short codes or nothing), which colors and patterns to use, and which projection draws the world. This guide takes each decision in turn and names its trade-offs, so the finished map says what you mean.

What shading, pins and labels can each show

Shading fills an area, such as a country, a state or a province. It answers the question 'which places?' very well and the question 'where inside the place?' not at all. Pins mark a point: a city, a trailhead, a single building. They answer 'where exactly?' but crowd together when many places sit close to one another. Labels add names, and they quickly clutter a map if every place gets one.

Marks for a travel map and their limits
MarkBest forLimit
Solid shadingWhole countries, states or provincesSmall places can vanish on a world map
Graded shadingHow much or how often, from light to darkNeeds a legend, and similar shades are hard to compare
PinsSpecific cities and sites, and very small countriesOverlap when places are close together
Outline onlyA want-to-go list that should not look visitedWeak on a busy map
LabelsNaming placesClutter; use codes or a numbered key when space runs out

Small countries and islands are the usual trouble. On a world map, a micro-state may be narrower than a single pin, so shading alone makes it disappear. A small pin on top of the shaded area solves the problem. The travel map editor draws countries and, for some large countries, their states and provinces, so shading works at two levels. The same logic applies wherever you build the map.

Colors and patterns that everyone can read

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, published by the W3C, state the principle in one line: color is not used as the only visual means of conveying information. The advice that goes with it is to add shape or text. For a travel map, that means each category should differ in more than hue. The National Eye Institute notes that a second type of deficiency makes blue and yellow look alike, so swapping red and green for blue and yellow only moves the problem.

Lightness is the reliable second signal. The W3C guidance explains that colors differing in lightness as well as in hue count as an extra visual distinction when their contrast ratio is at least 3:1. ColorBrewer, a color tool for cartography from Cynthia Brewer and Pennsylvania State University, builds its sequential schemes this way: light colors for low values and dark colors for high values. It also offers a filter for color-blind-safe schemes.

How the projection changes what the eye reads

A flat map has to stretch the globe somewhere. In the Mercator projection, areas far from the equator look much larger than areas near it. That matters for a travel map, because shaded area reads as progress. A shaded country at a high latitude can look larger than a shaded country on the equator that covers more ground. Equal-area projections keep areas in proportion, while bending shapes. The U.S. Geological Survey's working manual on map projections describes the main families and what each one preserves.

You do not need to become a cartographer. A sensible default for a world overview is an equal-area or compromise projection, and a local projection for a close-up of one country or region. The guide to map projections explains the options in plain terms.

Labels follow the same logic as marks: fewer is better. Name only the places that matter, use two-letter codes when space is tight, and put the rest in a key. The guides to map symbols and legends and political versus physical maps show how professional maps handle the same trade-offs.

Match the style to the job

The right style depends on where the map will be seen. A wall map is read from a distance, so it needs big shapes, high contrast and very few labels. A map in a notebook is read up close and can carry more detail. A map shared on a screen may be viewed on a phone, where thin outlines and small text disappear. Decide the setting first, then choose the style.

Before you settle on a style
  • Each category differs in more than hue, using lightness, pattern or outline
  • A legend explains every shade and symbol
  • Small countries and islands have pins or markers
  • Labels are limited to places that matter, or replaced by codes
  • The projection suits the area shown, and you know what it distorts
  • You checked the map in grayscale or at the size it will be viewed

If you also keep both a visited list and a wish list, give them clearly different looks, for example solid fill for one and outline for the other. The guide to building a want-to-go list shows how to organize the second list so that the two never blur together on the map.

Common mistakes with travel map styles

  • Using red and green as the only difference

    This is the pair that the most common color vision deficiency confuses. Add lightness, a pattern or an outline so the categories survive without hue.

  • Giving visited and want-to-go places the same look

    When both lists use one shade, the map overstates your progress. Use a clearly different treatment for each, such as solid fill and outline only.

  • Using too many categories

    Five or six shades are hard to tell apart and harder to remember. Two or three, each with a distinct pattern, are easier to read than a rainbow.

  • Ignoring size distortion

    Shaded area is read as progress, and some projections inflate high latitudes. Choose a projection that suits the area shown, and mention it if size matters.

  • Labeling every place

    Names pile on top of each other and hide the shapes beneath. Label the places that matter and move the rest to a numbered key or a legend.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best color scheme for a travel map?

No scheme is best for every map. For amounts, such as number of visits, use one hue from light to dark. For categories, use a few colors that also differ in lightness or pattern. ColorBrewer lets you filter schemes marked color-blind safe, which is a good starting point.

Should I use pins or shading?

Use shading for whole areas and pins for exact points. Many maps use both: shading for countries or states, and pins for small places or specific sites. Pins are the better choice for very small countries that vanish under shading.

Which projection should a world travel map use?

For a world overview, an equal-area or compromise projection keeps sizes fairer than Mercator. Equal Earth, Robinson and Mollweide are examples. For a single country or region, a local projection usually looks better. Whatever you pick, know what it distorts.

Do I need a legend on a personal map?

Yes, as soon as the map has more than one meaning. A small legend makes the map understandable to anyone you share it with, and to you in a few years, when you may have forgotten what the stripes meant.

How many colors are too many?

As a working limit, three or four categories are enough for most travel maps. Beyond that, viewers must keep checking the legend. If you need more detail, use pins, labels or a second map for the extra layer.

Sources

  1. Understanding Success Criterion 1.4.1: Use of Color W3C Web Accessibility Initiative
  2. Color Blindness National Eye Institute
  3. ColorBrewer: Color Advice for Maps Cynthia Brewer, Mark Harrower and The Pennsylvania State University
  4. Color scheme types (ColorBrewer) Cynthia Brewer, Mark Harrower and The Pennsylvania State University
  5. Map projections: A working manual (Professional Paper 1395) U.S. Geological Survey

Keep a record of the places you have been, and see what share of the world you have covered.

Open the travel map editor